4 Alarm Cheddar

Cow's Milk Cheese


4 Alarm Cheddar is made by the award winning Milton Creamery (makers of Prairie Breeze) in Iowa. This is a unique cheddar that has not 1, but  4 different peppers within the body of the cheese to give it a complex heat and a beautiful marbleization. Ghost peppers, Chili, Chipotle and Jalapeño peppers combine to create layers of flavor that offer a medium burn.

Local Pickup Ordering

Orders will be fulfilled during hours of operation. If orders are placed after hours or within an hour of closing, your order will be ready the next day we are open.

1. Order Online

Browse our products, add them to your cart, and place your order. During checkout, please note if you cannot receive text messages, and we can call instead.

2. We Will Contact You To Arrange Pick Up

You will receive a text message or a call when your order is ready. Curbside or instore pickup is available, and we can arrange and agree a time within store hours that suits you.  You can even arrange pick up at the Farmers Market in Rochester! (seasonal)

3. Arrive At Store At Arranged Time

For curbside pick up  – your order will be available for you in our outdoor cooler in our porch area.

For instore pick up – let us know you are here for order pick up and we will get your order for you.